Posts Categorized: Communiqués

An Additional Note on Walt Whitman

John Burroughs, in his 1867 Notes on Walt Whitman as Poet and Person (section XXXI) employs three birds in his account of the necessity of encountering objects in the fullness and richness of their surroundings and histories:

It must be ever present to the true artist in his attempt to report Nature, that every object as it stands in the sequence of cause and effect has a history which involves its surroundings, and that the depth of the interest which it awakens in us is in proportion as its integrity in this respect is preserved. In Nature we are prepared for any opulence of color, or vegetation, or freak of form, or display of any kind, by the preponderance of the common, ever-present features of the earth. I never knew how beautiful a red-bird was till I saw one darting through the recesses of a shaggy old hemlock wood. In like manner the bird of the naturalist can never interest us like the thrush the farm boy heard singing in the cedars at twilight as he drove the cows to pasture, or like the swallow that flew gleefully in the air above him as he picked the stones from the early May meadow.

Why might Burroughs, close friend of Whitman, have insisted on a sequence of three birds to illustrate his point? Theories and insights are welcome.

The Third Bird and the Death of Semsem

The following is an excerpt from a folktale from the present nation of Vanuatu, about a dangerous man-eating demon named Semsem who is dispatched by some brave islanders, a mother and her sons. Semsem, pierced by spears and weakened, falls upon the ground:

The mother and the boys, fearing that he might not be dead, asked some small birds to go close to the body and see if life were really extinct. One bird touched the body of Semsem with its head and flew away in terror. This is a bird that has red feathers on the top of its head today. Another bird, more venturesome, put its head and shoulders into a wound. This is a bird that has red feathers on its head and shoulders today. A third bird went directly through the body entering at one wound and coming out by another. The bird is almost entirely red today. […] When the third bird came out of the body of Semsem the victors were certain that the giant was dead.

If in the Kashmiri tale below, it is the third bird’s task to transform the beast into a man, here it is the third bird’s task to confirm that the beast will not return, but only by daring to abide within, to inhabit, and finally to traverse and break free of the latter.

—Corresponding Secretary

Concerning a Kashmiri Tale…

A recent submission to Notes and Queries from a correspondent in Uttar Pradesh who is an amateur historian of the Order, and an aficionado of its ways:

“Dear Sirs and Madams: What most excellent happiness I am feeling in this day, for coming upon — MOST unexpectedly, I am telling you! — a remarkable moment for a reader who is knowledgable about the Birds and Birding and all Bird matters. To wit: In the reading of Reverend J. Hinton Knowles, F.R.G.S., M.R.A.S., et&, and more specifically FOLK TALES OF KASHMIR (London: Trübner & Co., Ludgate Hill, 1888 — picture included), I find myself lately discovering a story of tremendous and very new surprising excitement. More specifically I am now referring to the “Story of the Three Birds” that finds itself within the tale “Saiyid and Said,” at page 90 of the aforementioned Book to which I have referred (also picture being included here).  If I am not very woefully in error on this occasion, this is unmistakably a story relating to the work of the Order in the KUSH region most definitely of India in older times! I am currently in need to do further researches, but the THIRD BIRD here has the POWER by his ministrations to make the human being of a non-human type of creature — and this will surely be most familiar to many who are greatly dedicated to the ORDER, as a metaphor or allegory of the humanizing effects of the Practice, it is certain.”

Both images follow — the title page, and the story in question, which comes to the Editorial Committee as a real discovery of great interest.  More work is certainly needed, as it is not clear if this is an interpolation by Knowles (as a little “easter egg” for his metropolitan readers familiar with the Order), or points to residue of Central Asian Practices of greater antiquity — perhaps associated lineally with the texts discussed in the recent work on the Rülek Scrolls.  More work is needed.


Screen Shot 2014-10-16 at 10.56.22 PM


Screen Shot 2014-10-16 at 10.28.17 PM


Screaming at the Eyes

The Proceedings recently received a very interesting submission concerning Walt Whitman’s possible association with the Order.  The brief essay focuses almost entirely on the haunting and mysterious line in canto III of “Song of Myself”:
“Shall I postpone my acceptation and realization and scream at my eyes?”
It would seem, according to the author of the piece (now out for peer review) that “acceptation” was a term adopted by some of the Fourierist cells as an alternate name for “Attending.”  The essay goes on to allege that “screaming at one’s eyes” was a form of Negation developed by Whitman himself.  If the analysis is correct, considerable avenues for further exploration would obviously immediately be opened before those equipped for the necessary labor. It is, however, too early to say if the author is fully in command of his/her argument. Closer work with Whitman’s oeuvre is wanted, and the membership is encouraged to take up this happy task.

Beautiful Birdness

There have been rumors around DeLillo for some time, of course. This is one of the lines that seems most clearly to point to his engagement with the Practice. Further work is needed…

“He watched several gulls veering and saw a hundred other gulls positioned on a slope, all facing the same way, motionless, regardful, joined in consciousness, in beautiful empty birdness, waiting for the signal to fly.” (Don DeLillo, Underworld, 186.)

A Clue against Clues

There is no property less congenial to a Bird, as we understand that fugitive spirit, than a clue: for a clue leads elsewhere. Therefore it would seem that the work of Giovanni Morelli, AKA Ivan Lermolieff—in which he proposes the value of such unregarded accidentals of the pictorial art as the shape of an ear, taken as keys to the mysteries of attribution, and a sovereign antidote to the sleights of the forgers—his work must be anathema to the Order. Some evidence has come to light, however, suggesting not only Morelli’s contact with practitioners in Germany, but that this very notion of clue might have arisen precisely as a tactic of negation. Which possibility reminds those of us concerned with the history of the Order that its traces may be discernible in sites not only of apparent neglect or indifference, but of perfect opposition.

It is hoped that the documents in question will be brought to light in due course. In the meantime, Morelli’s Die Werke italienischer Meister (1880), here in its first English translation as Italian Painters (1892), is offered to the reader’s powers of induction.

Upcoming Lecture

November 6, 6:30 – 8pm. Grand Gallery, RISD Museum, Providence (RSVP). “Prosopopoeia as Protocol—The Hale Experiments and Object-Oriented Ventriloquy during the Cold War”





The general problem of deriving information (intelligence, actionable data, orienting indices) from “objects” has long preoccupied scientists, philosophers, and members of the clandestine services. New documentation has recently come to light that bears on this important subject, and a full airing of these striking sources is urgently wanted. In brief, there are now reasons to believe that individuals apparently associated with the CIA may well have embarked, in the early 1960s, on a notably non-traditional program of interrogatory investigations into the secret life of brute matter. Were these experiments conducted in association with associates of the Order of the Third Bird? It seems likely. Further work is needed, but on the evening of 6 November 2014, members of the Editorial Committee of ESTAR(SER) will provide a preliminary research report.

About ESTAR(SER): The Esthetical Society for Transcendental and Applied Realization (now incorporating the Society of Esthetic Realizers) is an established body of private, independent scholars who work collectively to recover, scrutinize, and (where relevant) draw attention to the historicity of the Order of the Third Bird.

Part of a series of lectures and workshops entitled It, Me, You, Us: Close Encounters with Interpretation, exploring varied ways of writing about and engaging with art, with an emphasis on the sensory, the subjective, and the shared.

RSVP requested. Register here.